Is DeFi halal or haram overall?
Question context
CoinStudy's answer
Research opinion from the CoinStudy Sharia team. Not a fatwa.
DeFi cannot receive one universal ruling. It is a category not a product. Lending protocols like Aave are Haram due to interest-based lending. Perpetual futures DEXs are Haram due to zero-sum leveraged trading and funding rates. Algorithmic stablecoins with stability fees are Haram. Yield tokenization of interest-bearing instruments is Haram. Basic DEX trading for spot swaps is Halal With Concerns. Liquidity provision is conditional on the chairman's two-condition test. Native Proof of Stake staking is a scholarly grey area. The ruling belongs to the specific economic relationship of each specific protocol. Understanding what each protocol actually does financially is the only honest basis for assessment.
Related questions
- Is buying Pendle YT tokens on SpaceX xStock halal for xPoints? SpaceX pays no dividends so no yield accrues.
- Is Prophet Market halal? The AI takes the other side of every trade instead of humans. Does trading against an AI change the Islamic ruling? Can I farm the airdrop by using the platform?
- If I buy yield tokens of a halal company like SpaceX xStock on Pendle just to earn XPoints for an airdrop, is that halal? My intention is not to earn yield, only to collect the points.
- Is Nexo (NEXO) halal? It seems more trustworthy than regular DeFi because it is regulated, has Fidelity as a custody partner, and just relaunched in the US with full compliance ?
- Is the CoinMarketCap 20 Index (CMC20) halal? It tracks the top 20 cryptocurrencies so I thought it would be a good way to get diversified halal crypto exposure in one token.